Global Macro – EURO Tumbles On Increased ECB Stimulus

Global financial markets were very nervous going into yesterday’s European Central Bank (ECB) policy meeting…..and for good reason. Since the last ECB meeting in October, the EUR/USD has dropped over 6% and the US SP 500 has gained just over 5%. In this sense, expectations were high that ECB chief Mario Draghi would announce additional stimulus measures, extend the current QE timeline, or both.

Over the last 12 months, the ECB has often fallen short of expectations, disappointed investors and triggered violent price responses in the currency and equities markets. In fact, five out of the last six ECB meetings have ended with the EUR/USD trading higher and global equity markets trading sharply lower.

In the lead up to yesterday’s announcement, some analysts suggested that the ECB was concerned about the lower level of the EURO, and that the recent string of better-than-expected economic data out of the Euro-zone would allow the introduction of tapering monthly bond purchases. However, after listening to Mr Draghi’s press conference, it’s clear that the ECB wants to see a lower EURO and considers a weaker currency an integral component to reaching their 2% inflation target by 2018.

The consensus for the new ECB policy measures was for the bank to extend the duration for six months, keep the monthly rate at €80 billion and expand the bond pool to reduce the risk of supply shortages next year. Instead, Mr Draghi announced the QE program would be extended by another nine months but the monthly amount would be reduced to €60 billion per month. At first, the EUR/USD spiked 120 points higher to 1.0870, and Euro stocks dropped sharply,  on the idea that scaling back the monthly purchases was the start of an exit strategy.

The tapering effect on the market was brief as Mr Draghi spent most of his press conference talking about the possibility of more stimulus, the acute downside risks to the Euro-zone economy and even saying that “there was no tapering in sight.” The math is pretty easy; six months of €80 billion per month equals €480 billion, while nine months of €60 billion per month equals €540 billion. By any measure, that’s a lot of Euros that need to be put to work, which is why G-7 stock indices all rallied strongly.

On balance, the ECB made a decisive policy move to further weaken the EURO, reflate the Euro-zone economies and attempt (again) to kick-start some inflationary momentum. As a result, the downside price trend in the EUR/USD will likely continue and G-7 equity indices will remain buoyant

European Central Bank (ECB)

US stocks rose to fresh highs overnight, extending gains as the European Central Bank (ECB) said it would extend the duration of its stimulus program but reduce the monthly volume.

Both US and European stocks initially sold off as investors concluded the bank was tapering its program of quantitative easing , but reversed quickly during Mario Draghi’s press conference. The ECB chief made clear that the extension of the program by 12 months would add more stimulus even though the monthly purchase rate would drop from €80 billion per month to €60 billion per month. This pencils out to €560 billion in fresh stimulus compared to the market’s expectations €480 billion.

The Stoxx Europe 600 index gained 1.2% to close at its highest level since January.

Looking forward, we see the ECB decision as generally positive for the ongoing bullish theme for G-7 stock markets.

Chart - EUR/USD
Chart – EUR/USD

European Central Bank (ECB) Meeting

US and European equities pushed higher as investors showed confidence ahead of today’s key European Central Bank (ECB) meeting in Frankfurt, Germany. All the major indices including the FTSE, DAX, CAC, DOW and SP 500 posted gains in excess of 1.5% on the day.

The ECB is widely expected to announce an extension of its massive Quantitative Easing (QE) stimulus program and may even increase, or expand, the scope of the asset pool to include European corporate bonds and equities.

The ECB has been the most aggressive central bank in providing monetary stimulus this year. Since March, it has been buying €80 billion of assets per month, mainly in the form of Government debt. Although the program is scheduled to expire in March 2017, analysts are expecting at least a six-month extension to be announced today.

As a note of caution, it’s important that ECB chief Mario Draghi rejects any talk about an early tapering of the monthly asset purchases. Just the rumor of a “scaling back” of stimulus before the September ECB meeting sparked a sharp sell-off in G-7 equities and credit markets.

However, with the US FOMC meeting scheduled for next week, our base case is that the ECB statement will not mention tapering and, instead, focus on the technical adjustments to the QE program. On balance we expect this scenario to have a neutral to bullish impact on G-7 equity markets.      

Chart - Dow Jones
Chart – Dow Jones

 

ETF Watch – iShares Europe (Italian Election Outcome)

Without a sitting government, it’s difficult to see how there can be any official help for Italy’s beleaguered banking sector. In short, now that the “No” vote has prevailed, Italy’s banking system is for all intents and purposes insolvent.

In addition, the size of Italy’s government debt is also a concern. Depending on which figures you look at, the total outstanding Italian debt is more than €2 trillion, which will have to be serviced even if the Italian voters someday choose to leave the European Union.

On balance we feel that the brunt of the market fallout will be felt across the European Union. However, after the sharp rally in global stocks during the month of November, this referendum news could very well trigger some re-balancing of of financial positions going into the upcoming ECB and the FOMC meetings.

Chart - iShares Europe
Chart – iShares Europe

Italian Exit Poll

Early results from Italian exit polls suggest voters have overwhelmingly rejected the constitutional reforms proposed by PM Matteo Renzi. He has pledged to resign if the referendum failed to get a “Yes” majority.

Polls from both leading national broadcasters show the “No” vote beating the “Yes” vote by an average of 56% to 43%.

If verified, a defeat of this magnitude could prompt fresh market volatility, especially in the banking sector which has lost almost half its value this year on the Milan bourse, hit by fears over its huge exposure to bad loans accumulated during years of economic downturn.

In early Asian trade, the EUR/USD is over 1% lower at 1.0540 and the local XJO Index has opened fractionally lower.

 

Global Macro

At this point, the FED Funds futures market is pricing in a 95% certainty of an upward adjustment to the Fed Funds target and a 40% chance of another adjustment by May of 2017.

Sunday will be the Presidential elections in Austria and the Parliamentary referendum in Italy. Between these two events, it’s more likely to expect a market moving result from the elections in Austria. If the Italian people vote “No” to the constitutional changes proposed on the ballot, the worst case result is that PM Matteo Renzi will be replaced by some other non-elected technocrat designated by the EU.

However, if the Freedom Party leader, Norbert Hofer, is elected as the next president of Austria, his promises to hold a “Brexit” style referendum, combined with his general disdain for EU policymakers in Brussels, could pressure G-7 equity markets lower.

USD and US Stock indexes look technically stretched; internal volume and “breadth of market” indicators are showing signs of rolling over. It seems the slightest fundamental disruption to the current expansionary theme could trigger a pullback.

Chart - Dow Jones Index
Chart – Dow Jones Index
Chart - NASDAQ Index
Chart – NASDAQ Index

US Banks vs Technolgy

Over the last five years, one of the least important concerns for US Corporate Treasurers has been the forward cost of funding. However, over the last two months, the sharp rise across the US Treasury curve has exposed some notable differences in how banks perform versus technology companies perform in a rising interest rate environment.

Since October 1st, the yield on the US 10-year note has surged close to 90 basis points from 1.55% to 2.44%. This is nearly a 60% increase and has helped US banking stocks, while hurting some big technology names.

For example, Since October 1st, shares of J.P.Morgan have climbed over 20% from $67.00 per share to over $81.00 per share. During that same period of time, shares of Facebook have dropped from $133.00 per share to just under $115.00 per share; a 13.5% drop.

Chart - JP Morgan
Chart – JP Morgan

 

Australian Banks – Credit Growth

Australian consumers borrowed less in the month of October with RBA data showing private credit growth at 0.5% (5.3% year on year) versus a YoY rate of 5.4% last month. A closer look at the data suggests Australians are interested in buying real estate and not much else. Even though housing credit growth was flat last month at 6.4%, the pace is still well above the 4.4% growth in Business credit and the rate of Personal credit; which actually dropped to -1.1% Year on year.  It’s likely that the growth in housing credit has been supported by the RBA’s rate cuts in May and August. However, the RBA won’t miss the fact that lending over the last 12 months has a flat to lower trajectory, which may influence their policy directives going forward.

Australian banks continue to push up against the top end of the their price channels. We’re mindful of the rally in US banks helping to boost investor sentiment towards the sector, yet there is limited evidence domestically  of any pickup in earnings on the horizon.

Chart - CBA
Chart – CBA