Bank Results – Weak Revenue Trends

The soft underlying revenue trends which impacted the other major bank
results over the last week were obvious in CBA’s Q3 result. Offsetting the weak revenue trends in the major banks has been a strong performance on asset quality.

We see downside risks building around regulatory change & economic weakness leading to higher bad debts.

CBA FY18 forecasts net profit to remain flat at $9.8b, EPS $5.50, placing the stock on a  forward yield of 4.9%.

The Algo Engine has triggered a buy signal on the higher low formation in ANZ. We’re happy to look at this from a  very short term perspective but remain on the short side of the banks and we’re inclined to sell any technical bounce from the current levels.

NOTE: The Australian Government announced the introduction of the Bank levy in its 2017 budget. Based on the Treasury estimates this levy will raise $6.2billion which will reduce earnings by up to 5% for the majors’.

Chart – CBA

 

CBA Nears Key Resistance

Australian banks are currently trading at lofty levels and close to significant chart resistance points.

We consider CBA to be most vulnerable to a down side correction considering the technical pattern and the premium at which it trades to its peers.

Going back to December 2015, there have been four occasions when CBA shares traded into the $85.00  to $86.00 price range before rolling over for a 5 to 10% correction. At this point, we are looking for a technical move back to the $80.00 level.

Fundamentally, huge consumer debt burdens, stagnant domestic wages growth and an overheated housing market will likely act as a headwind to further meaningful price appreciation.

Investors holding long CBA positions can look to sell covered calls into June, or buy the May $83.00 outright put option.

 

CBA- Back to the $80.00 Handle?

Shares of Commonwealth Bank (CBA) have been trading below the 30-day moving average of $83.80 for the last four consecutive trading sessions.

As the technical picture continues to deteriorate, we have looked at some previous chart resistance levels which could now act as price support.

Between late January and early February, CBA tested the $81.10 level three times over the course of 10 trading sessions; this will be the first key support level.

However, going back to May of last year, CBA shares failed to break above $80.00 five times before extending higher in July. We feel that this is a more significant support level and a reasonable medium-term target.

Investors and subscribers will remember that we sold European-style call options on CBA in late January. By selling the $83.01 strike-price into March, we were able to collect $2.50 in option premium and still hold the shares to collect the $2.00 dividend paid in February.

Those options will expire this Thursday.

As such, we will look to reset the derivative overlay strategy in CBA on corrective price moves higher.

Chart-CBA

Banks – Chart Update

US banks, (see chart below of JP Morgan), are breaking to the upside of their recent consolidation range, and this is likely driving the rebound in the share price of the Australian banks.

NAB reported a 1% fall in earnings following weak revenue growth and a pickup in expense growth. Bendigo Bank failed to deliver growth at the top or bottom line.

CBA reported slightly ahead of expectations with underlying profit growth of 2.8% or $4.9b for the half. ANZ’s quarterly update, (released Friday), reported a 31% rise in profits to $2b for the 3 months to December.

Across all banking results, the NIM or net interest margins, remain under pressure, as does top line revenue growth. These are the same concerns which caused the 10% sell off in banks at the start of this year.

We’ll watch with interest how prices behaves in both the XJO and our major banks this week, as we commence trading with price levels similar to the peak of early January.

Chart – CBA
Chart – ANZ
Chart – WBC
Chart – NAB
CHART – JPM

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Commonwealth Bank

Shares of Commonwealth bank have opened 2% higher to $84.50 after reporting a record first-half profit of $4.9 billion.

The result was 6% higher than the previous record reported in the first half of last year. An interim fully franked dividend of $1.99 was declared, which was 1 cent higher than expected.

Upside price momentum could be tempered as the bank announced net interest margin was lowered to 2.11% from 2.15% and their wealth management division saw a net profit drop of 34% compared to the same period last year.

Chart – CBA

Chart Update – Banks

Goldman Sachs and JP Morgan remain within the consolidation range which began in early December.

In our local market we’ve seen BOQ & BEN sell off 10% from the January peak-to-trough. NAB reported weak revenue growth and higher than expected expenses, leading to a 1% fall in profit.

CBA report their half year results on Wednesday, we expect NPAT of $4.8b and DPS $2.00. 3 – 5% underlying EPS growth on the same time last year.

ANZ corrected 10% from peak-to-trough.

We’ll watch the US banks in the weeks ahead to see which way they break from their current consolidation range.

Chart – Goldman Sachs
Chart – JP Morgan
Chart – CBA

 

 

Early Days on The Bank Hedge

We’ve been running a hedge on the Australian banks; CBA through an in-the-money European March option, NAB using an in-the-money American February option and WBC a longer-term call option. In ANZ our preference has been to exit the trade altogether.

On Friday, our domestic banks started to see some profit taking and the catalyst could’ve been selling ahead of the US banking results and/or the announcement of weaker export data out of China.

JP Morgan and BoA’s results , released last night, were adequate on the bottom line but both companies missed on the revenue front. Increased dividends and share-buybacks helped support what otherwise would’ve been viewed as weak results.

Chart – CBA
Chart – WBC
Chart – NAB
Chart – ANZ

 

 

Australian Bank Profit Announcements – Key Dates

Bank profit announcements start in February with the following key dates worth noting.

SUN 9 February, BEN 13 February, CBA 15 February along with 1Q17 trading updates from ANZ and NAB in February.

Following the recent rally in bank shares, we see the current trading range as full value, therefore, placing the banks at risk of being buffeted by any increase in market volatility.  Although net interest margins have improved, the prospects of earnings growth is modest with the outlook between 1% – 4% growth at both top and bottom-line.

We also remain concerned that the cycle for bad debts is likely to rise from the current historic low levels.

Charts – Aust Bank ETF

 

 

ASX Banks and Financials

Currently, ASX leading Financials are being dragged higher as the US equity rally continues into the lead up to their fourth quarter earnings results. We’re somewhat sceptical of the valuation support and yesterday started hedging our banking exposure in client portfolios. This was done through using in-the-money European-style calls over CBA and slightly in the money February calls over NAB, as two examples.

In the case of CBA, we stay exposed to the February dividend and franking credit but have hedged a price pullback of up to 5% between now and March.

In NAB, we’ve hedged to a similar extend but without the need to protect the dividend. NAB’s next payment period is not until May

Chart – ANZ
Chart – NAB
Chart – WBC
Chart – ASX
Chart – CPU

 

Commonwealth Bank – Visa Inc Sale

Shares of the Commonwealth Bank (CBA) posted a new high for the year at $82.65 as the bank announced it has sold its remaining stake in the US financial services company, Visa Inc.

The CBA sold its stake in Visa for A$439 million, realizing a post-tax profit of A$278 million. Against this profit, CBA has also announced a one-off accelerated amortization on certain capitalized software assets, totalling A$275 million.

While the accelerated amortization is more than offset by the profit on the sale of the bank’s Visa holdings, we see this move as reducing the potential for earnings uplift going into 2017. As such, heading into the February dividend, we see price resistance at or near the $83.00 level.

 

Chart - CBA
Chart – CBA